COLUMNISTS
The Indian Express
Monday, April 05, 2004
 
 
 
  SEARCH IE
  IE ARCHIVE
   Search by Date
  SERVICES
 
  Free Money Transfers to India
  Matrimonials
  New friendships, romance...
  Send Gifts Online New
  Express Travel
  Personalised Predictions
  GROUP SITES
 
  Expressindia
  The Indian Express
  The Financial Express
  Screen
  City Newslines
  Kashmir Live
  Latest News
  Express Cricket
  Loksatta
  Lokprabha
  Express Computer
  North American
Edition [Print]
  CHANNELS
 
  Astrology
  Shopping
  Express Classifieds
  Express Estates
  Express Money
  Express Travel
  SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
  Free Newsletter
  Wireless Express
  SYNDICATIONS
 
  RSS Feeds
 
Select Columnists
 
Everybody loves Rahul
Yet Amethi is a neglected constituency, a mirror image of the Congress
 
Mail this story
Print this story
To travel with Rahul Gandhi to the Amethi parliamentary constituency, is to travel to the heart of feudal Uttar Pradesh. Vast, swelling crowds line narrow dirt tracks. In fierce heat, hundreds wait, sweating, for hours at crossings, on rooftops, in town squares to catch a glimpse of their favourite family member. Mango and neem trees are strung with buntings. Posters of the Gandhis glare down from giant hoardings.

Women take the lead in extreme adoration. Rahul is the embodiment of a range of male relatives. He is their boyfriend/ husband/ brother/ brother-in-law/ son/ nephew/ grandson. Even men giggle flirtatiously as he passes by in his white Qualis, bursting with marigold garlands (with the defeated looking Capt Satish Sharma beaming irrelevantly in the back seat). Hundreds of Youth Congress cadres thunder past on Hero Hondas, Enfields and Rajdoot motorbikes, a mob of scruffy outriders escorting their treasured VIP. “He is the only thing his poor mother has!” a woman in Lohsanpur village sobs, “She lost everything. Lost her husband. Lost her mother-in-law. Now the poor widow hands us her eklauta hira (only jewel). God bless him!”

 
Send your comments to the columnist
Name
Your E-Mail
Your Comments
 
The urban journalist, disapproving of dynasty, anxious about the Colombian girlfriend (does this mean a Colombian first lady in the future, for god’s sake?), agitated about the rootlessness of privileged folk and their pocket boroughs, is dismissed with an impatient roar from this unabashedly hysterical swarm: “You don’t understand. He is our son!”

And this in contemporary UP! Where Dalit and OBC assertion rampages forward, where ferocious caste politics has become the only ticket to capturing the gaddi at Lucknow, where the landscape is so highly politicised that almost every kutcha track in UP is marked by the familiar cavalcade of white ambassadors with flashing red lights. In UP, politics is not about issues or ideas. It’s about employment, social mobility, wealth, and yet, in this highly competitive and politically ambitious environment, Amethi strikes out as an island of old-fashioned surrender to the king.

Travel around the villages of Amethi and you can’t help feeling astounded at what a neglected constituency it is. For a seat as high-profile, as much in the public eye, there is a sharp contrast between the well-dressed scion in his crisp kurta pyjama and his wretched and destitute worshippers. Unemployment is brutal, over 80 per cent, only 40 per cent are literate or have access to drinking water. Electricity supply is non-existent in some areas, in others, it flickers for barely six hours a day. The soil in Amethi is sandy and salty, classified as usad or wasteland in which nothing grows, except scrub and small trees. The roads are appalling, dotted with deep potholes and ditches, and there are huge, untarred stretches of pebble tracks that look like dry river beds. Hutments are mud-daubed with thatched roofs, the price of kerosene is too high for the poor to cook even a single meal and there is no money to repair rundown schools or add to college facilities. Locals are quick to point out that Amethi was a jungle before the Gandhis arrived, that there was nothing here. Now, waving wheat fields, canals, compensation during disasters and institutions like the Sanjay Gandhi Hospital have transformed living conditions. Yet the decline since Rajiv Gandhi’s time is clear.

Industry in Amethi is ruined. Malvika Stainless Steel no longer functions as it used to. Cement factories have shut down. Samrat Cycles has shut down. And vast numbers have become unemployed as a result. As Rajeshwar Singh, a retired principal in a local Intermediate Collage pointed out, it is savage unemployment, rather than love for the Gandhis which is the reason for the huge crowds. There is a more chilling reason for the hundreds of families standing in the sun for hours. Not just loyalty but deep despair and absolutely nothing to do.

Politics in Amethi is a firmly closed shop. No local charismatic youth can ever aspire for the top political job because he can never hope to gain a ticket either from Sultanpur or from Amethi or from Rae Bareli. Local BSP members like Sripat Maurya and Suresh Kamal say they joined the BSP, not so much because they believe in the Dalit cause but because there are simply no opportunities in the Congress. The capture of the party by the Gandhis has meant that there is no chance of a political career for anyone else. To be a Congressman in Amethi is to be an also-ran. Indeed, the closed-ness of Congress politics, the fawning loyalty of its cadres, the absence of democratic functioning within the party, the absence of industrial development or of a modern party machine, the ridiculous dependence on a single “family member” makes Amethi a mirror image of the contemporary Congress.

In this sense, the Gandhi family has been a blessing and a curse for Amethi, just as it is a blessing and curse for the Congress. By treating Amethi as a pocket borough, local support has been taken for granted. There is a belief that even if there is no development, Amethi will remain bound to the family. Amethi dreams hopelessly of Rajiv, caught in a time warp, and Congress still believes in its god-given right to rule.

But ironically, like with the rest of UP, there are stirrings of change. Out of five assembly segments,the Congress only holds one, two are with the Samjawadi Party. Last year, the BSP won a seat in a by-election, although later the candidate switched to the SP. Dalit and OBC identities are now being strongly asserted, and there is a constant search for a political platform that will give space to this new assertiveness.

Candidate Grandson then bears a unique burden. He, unlike his grandmother and father, is a dynast in times of galloping caste ambitions. It’s no longer enough to simply be Rajiv ka beta and Indira ka pota. If he is to answer the desperation in his constituents’ eyes, if he is to meet the caste challenge, then he will not only have to carry out development, but set in motion a semblance of democracy, both in Amethi, as well as in the Congress. If he wants his family business to survive, Rahul Gandhi has to work towards making his family name irrelevant.

 
Mail this story
Print this story
Select Columnists
 


Recent columns by Sagarika Ghosh
The iftaar party trap 06.06.05
Social Justice Pvt Ltd 04.05.05
Who’s afraid of Narendra Modi? 04.04.05
Secular=Communal 07.03.05
Dutiful sons aren’t youth icons 07.02.05
 
 
Go to Today's Edition  
For Columns between October 1999 to April 2002
   
 
 

People who read this Column also read
Sonia and PM: Synergy can do it
How the vote was lost
Family versus Parivar
It should be PM Sonia
The idea of Sonia Gandhi as PM
Full Coverage
Varanasi Blasts
Assembly Poll '06
The Bush Visit; March '06
Budget 2006-07
India-England Series
Rail Budget, 2006- 07
Bird Flu
India in Pakistan: 2006
Bofors Scam
Building house beaking Law
Bringing Back Bihar
Oil For Food Scandal: The Natwar Cloud
Manjunath S: Death on Duty
Killer Waves Hit India
Mumbai Blasts
Army's Muslim headcount
India Empowered
Kashmir Quake
Delhi Blasts
Chappell vs Ganguly
View from the Left
Chandigarh War Memorial
Missing Tigers
Defence Deals: What The CVC Found
Bihar Flood Scam
Cities And Their People
Karthikeyan: Driving India Forward
Budget 2005-06
Ambani Empire Divided
Bangalore Crumbling
Gujarat Riots
Dubey Murder
Walk the Talk
Travelogues
Petrol Pump Scam
Stamp of Shame
Cash on Camera
India-Pak Faceoff
Firing Line
   
 
   
About Us | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy |
   
© 2005: Indian Express Newspapers (Mumbai) Ltd. All rights reserved throughout the world.